Musings Report 2018-17 4-28-18 Kafka's Nightmare Emerges: China's "Social Credit Score"
You are receiving this email because you are one of the 500+ subscribers/major contributors to www.oftwominds.com.
For those who are new to the Musings reports: they are basically a glimpse into my notebook, the unfiltered swamp where I organize future themes, sort through the dozens of stories and links submitted by readers, refine my own research and start connecting dots which appear later in the blog or in my books. As always, I hope the Musings spark new appraisals and insights. Thank you for supporting the site and for inviting me into your circle of correspondents.
Welcome to April's MUS (Margins of the Unfiltered Swamp)
The last Musings of the month is a free-form exploration of the reaches of the fecund swamp that is the source of the blog, Musings and my books.
Kafka's Nightmare Emerges: China's "Social Credit Score"
China is rapidly building out a Total Surveillance State on a scale that far surpasses any government surveillance program in the West.
The scope of this surveillance is so broad and pervasive that it borders on science fiction:
Life Inside China’s Total Surveillance State (8 min video)
China Aims For Near-Total Surveillance, Including in People's Homes ("Sharp Eyes" nationwide surveillance network)
"You're Being Controlled All The Time" - An Inside Look At China's "Social Credit Score"
China Assigns Every Citizen A 'Social Credit Score' To Identify Who Is And Isn’t Trustworthy
It's well known that the intelligence agencies in America seek what's known as Total Information Awareness, the goal being to identify and disrupt terrorists before they can strike.
This level of surveillance has run partly aground on civil liberties concerns, which still have a fragile hold on the American psyche and culture.
The implicit goal of China's Total Surveillance State is to control the citizenry and root out any dissent before it threatens The Communist Party's hold on power, but the explicit goal is a behavioral psychologist's dream: to reward "positive social behaviors" and punish "negative social behaviors" via a "Social Credit Score."
There is something breathtakingly appealing about this goal to anyone in a position of power: imagine being able to catch miscreants who smoke in no-smoking zones, who jaywalk, who cheat people online, and of course, who say something negative about those in power.
But let's ask a simple question of China's vast surveillance system: what if it makes mistakes? What if one of those thousands of cameras mis-identifies a citizen breaking some minor social code, and over time, does so enough times to trigger negative consequences for the innocent citizen?
What recourse does the citizen have? It appears the answer is none, as the process is not strictly speaking judicial; the system appears to be largely automated.
Here's a second question: is the scoring system truly transparent, or can insiders place their thumbs on the scale, so to speak, to exact revenge on personal enemies?
Question #3: Who has the power to change the weightings within the automated software? Will criticizing the government online generate 1 negative point this month but 10 points next month? How can citizens with a handful of negative points, some perhaps erroneous mis-identifications, avoid crossing the dreaded threshold if they don't know how the system is truly ranking various violations?
This aligns perfectly with the world envisioned by Kafka in his novels The Trial and The Castle.
Kafka's fictional accounts of power manifesting through an inpenetrable bureaucracy describe a world with two primary features:
1. The rules guiding the system are opaque to those enmeshed in the system
2. There is no recourse for those unjustly persecuted or convicted by the system
What is it like to inhabit such a world? I've assembled some insightful comments on Kafka's works from online resources.
Critic Michiko Kakutani:
"(his novels share)...the same paranoid awareness of shifting balances of power; the same atmosphere of emotional suffocation."
The Trial is "the story of a man arrested and prosecuted by a remote, inaccessible authority, with the nature of his crime revealed neither to him nor to the reader."
"The law in Kafka's works, rather than being representative of any particular legal or political entity, is usually interpreted to represent a collection of anonymous, incomprehensible forces. These are hidden from the individual but control the lives of the people, who are innocent victims of systems beyond their control."
"For Kafka, law 'has no meaning outside its fact of being a pure force of domination and determination.'"
Kafka's novel The Castle explores "the motif of an oppressive and intangible system" and "the seemingly endless frustrations of man's attempts to stand against the system."
China is creating Kafka's nightmare world as the perfection of centralized control of its citizenry.
The question is: will the Chinese people tolerate this as long as the current artificial financialized "prosperity" reigns? What will happen to their perception and tolerance when the debt-fueled "prosperity" blows away like the sands of the Taklimakan Desert?
From Left Field
WHERE THE GUNS GO: U.S. ARMS AND THE CRISIS OF VIOLENCE IN MEXICO (via LaserLefty)
Sliced Ketchup is coming whether we like it or not (Nicole D.)
Can Dirt Save the Earth? (via Joel M.) -- carbon sequestering: long but well worth a read...
Officials: Long Beach may miss payroll, start layoffs after bond fails (via Joel M.) -- taxpayers asked to borrow money to fund pensions...
WHY CAN'T WE FIX PUERTO RICO'S POWER GRID? (via LaserLefty)
Why You'll Want to Pour Dish Soap in Your Toilet Bowl -- trick to help unclog a toilet... might not work if somebody flushed something that isn't water soluble....
War Profiteers Vs. The People of the United States
Homeownership Does Not Guarantee Middle-Class Prosperity -- heresy!
Fed Officials Worry the Economy Is Too Good. Workers Still Feel Left Behind -- file under "duh"
Why we should bulldoze the business school -- authored by a fellow who's taught in biz schools for 20 years...
Speculative Attack (bitcoin demolishes fiat currencies) -- some red meat for the anti-crypto crowd...
"Of all forms of caution, caution in love is perhaps the most fatal to true happiness." Bertrand Russell
Thanks for reading--
charles |
|
