|
|
Musings Report 2023-10 3-4-23 Look Out Below
You are receiving this email because you are one of the subscribers/major contributors to www.oftwominds.com.
For those who are new to the Musings reports: they're a glimpse into my notebook, the unfiltered swamp where I organize future themes, sort through the dozens of stories and links submitted by readers, refine my own research and start connecting dots which appear later in the blog or in my books. As always, I hope the Musings spark new appraisals and insights. Thank you for supporting the site and for inviting me into your circle of correspondents.
Look Out Below
The stock market is always looking past "bad news" to front-run "good news."
Once it became clear that the Titanic was indeed going to sink, the stock market would rally on the prospect of sharp growth in lifeboat shares. In other words, never mind the bad news, let's look beyond that and find some reason to rally.
This is a pattern that's easily visible in the past two decades. When it became clear that Covid was becoming a global pandemic, the US stock market rallied for weeks, something that struck sober analysts as completely disconnected from reality. Eventually reality intruded and the market crashed.
The same dynamic was also apparent in the run-up to the 2000 dot-com implosion--stocks rallied right up to March 6, 2000, before starting a two-year long controlled demolition--and the 2008-09 stock market crash, when shares of visibly impaired General Motors and Fannie Mae both maintained lofty valuations that were completely disconnected from a painfully visible reality. (Fannie Mae shares went to near-zero in the subsequent crash.)
And so here we are again. The stock market is rallying despite overwhelming evidence that the US economy and global economy are heading for a deep recession.
The justifications are either 1) the economy is so robust, there will be no recession (the "no landing" scenario) or 2) the Federal Reserve will quickly "pivot" and start lowering interest rates and flood the financial sector with liquidity, i.e. "The Fed Put" will save the stock market, just as its done for the past 23 years.
This is completely detached from the painfully visible reality that the Fed and other central banks have finally awakened to the perverse consequences of "The Fed Put" (i.e. the policy of unleashing trillions in financial stimulus whenever the stock market swoons) and they are now responding to rallies based on front-running the (now viewed as guaranteed) Fed "save" of the stock market by reiterating their new policy which is to continue to tighten financial conditions and keep interest rates (bond yields) higher for longer.
In other words, they are explicitly stating that they won't "save" the stock market because of 1) inflation and 2) the need to destroy the moral hazard created by "The Fed Put."
In the heady front-running rally prior to the crash, all seems well. Employment is strong, consumers are spending, etc.
The problem with this euphoric confidence is there are lag times between sharp increases in the cost of capital and goods and services and employment and spending.
Notice how credit card balances have exploded higher. In previous recessions, reliance on credit cards to juice spending soared right up until the stock market began its free-fall. Then spending fell sharply.
The lag time is also visible in yield-curve inversions--long counted as a surefire precursor to recession. (When the 2-year Treasury bonds pays a higher yield than the long-term 30-year bond, this inverts the normal market in which longer-term bonds pay higher yields than short-term bonds.)
As analyst Tom McClellan recently noted, unemployment also lags, and then catches up quickly.
As analyst Gordon Long observed, stocks tend to "catch down" as yields rise. Why take all the risks inherent in a recessionary stock market when you can earn a safe 5% in Treasury bonds?
Many other indicators repeat the same message: we're at the cusp of a recession and market decline. Here is the Macro Index Spread.
Many commentators note how tightening financial conditions take months to work through the economy, eventually affecting consumer spending, commercial borrowing, housing valuations, tax receipts, etc.
Here is a chart of the Federal Reserve balance sheet, which has risen over ten-fold since 2008, from around $800 billion to $9 trillion. This is now shrinking, reducing liquidity available for speculative "animal spirits" and other manifestations of easy money.
Globally, the forces pushing costs higher (i.e. inflation) cannot be reversed. Consider this chart of labor costs in China. As labor costs skyrocket, higher costs must be passed on to consumers.
There are also less easily measured trends at work. One factor that is not tracked and therefore poorly understood is how close to the edge many small businesses are. Those that survived the Covid lockdown have had to raise prices just to cover the sharp increases in their own costs. Small business isn't making big margins; rather, they're absorbing costs to keep the doors open. As some costs decline, they won't drop prices, as they need to finally make a profit.
Many owners are hovering on the edge of burnout, having compensated for higher costs by working longer hours themselves.
Any decline in consumer spending will push many of these business owners to finally give up.
Another factor is the change in speculative psychology once "investors" (i.e. gamblers) finally accept that the Titanic is in fact going to sink, that is, the Fed is not going to bail out the stock market with newly issued trillions. We can anticipate the stair-step down as confidence slips to denial, then anger, then grief and finally, acceptance.
As I often note, making Plans B and C is free. Making plans for how we'll respond to recession and/or a protracted stock market decline takes nothing but time. It's very difficult to act decisively before the herd turns and panics, which is why so few manage to do so.
We cannot anticipate every impact a recession and stock market free-fall will have on our household, but we can anticipate the possibility our income and wealth will be negatively affected and belt-tightening may be prudent.
If the happy-crowd is right and there is no recession, having a plan didn't cost anything. But if the happy-crowd is wrong, those without a plan to act decisively before the herd panics will suffer more than those who had a plan and acted on it.
Highlights of the Blog
The Easy Jobs Are (Mostly) Gone 3/3/23
The Forces Upending the Global Economy Cannot be Reversed 3/1/23
Stainless Steal 2/26/23
Best Thing That Happened To Me This Week
A visit from my sister and niece, who as always was bearing thoughtful, generous gifts. Gratitude.
From Left Field
NOTE TO NEW READERS: This list is not comprised of articles I agree with or that I judge to be correct or of the highest quality. It is representative of the content I find interesting as reflections of the current zeitgeist. The list is intended to be perused with an open, critical, occasionally amused mind.
Many links are behind paywalls. Most paywalled sites allow a few free articles per month if you register. It's the New Normal.
‘Delicate as the seashore’: rare Frank Lloyd Wright home sells for $22m
The Teenager Leading the Smartphone Liberation Movement: Logan Lane gave up her smartphone. That changed her life.
Four Hypotheses About The Secular-Corporatist Global Elite
The Story of the Most Successful Tunnel Escape in the History of the Berlin Wall (via Chad D.)
Visualized: Ocean Plastic Waste Pollution By Country
Oral hygiene, mouthwash usage and cardiovascular mortality during 18.8 years of follow-up
TEOCAWKT: The end of cars as we know them?
US Navy to eradicate fitness test failures to improve retention of sailors (via Chad D.)
Pakistan on the Brink: What the Collapse of the Nuclear-Armed Regional Power Could Mean for the World
As China Reopens, Flight of Wealthy Chinese to Singapore Set to Accelerate
"What athletes and academics have in common: they take a felicitous, enjoyable, and playful activity and transform it into a source of pain." Nassim Taleb
Thanks for reading--
charles |
|
|
|
|
|
