What If (Almost) All Assets Fall Together? (March 11, 2010)
Since virtually all asset classes rose together, why can't they all fall together, too?
Just as thought experiment: as the wheels fall off the bogus "global recovery" story, what if all asset classes fall together (with one exception)? This is what I call the "nowhere to hide" scenario, and the case for it can be made with the following charts.
Chart One: Tight correlation of assets.
Source: I Am a Futures Trader
Here is a 2000-tick chart of crude oil and the S&P 500 futures contract (E-Minis).
This sort of extreme correlation in markets which historically have not been tightly correlated smacks of manipulation and/or "hot money" borrowed from the Fed's quantitative easing punchbowl chasing all assets higher.
Or invent your own causal chains. Whatever the reason for this tight correlation, it suggests when one heads down, so will the other.
Chart Two: NASDAQ overlaid against other post-bubble equity markets.
This chart, courtesy of frequent contributor/blogger B.C., illustrates how the Shanghai market (blue dotted line) has tracked the NASDAQ 2000 bubble, crash and recovery quite well. It is now poised to collapse from its post-peak high.
The NASDAQ itself (solid black line) is tracking the post-crash Nikkei index (dotted purple line) quite closely, suggesting it is poised to roll over.
Chart Three: China's manufacturing orders are rolling over.
This chart is self-explanatory: China's new orders and new export orders are both rolling over as the $15 trillion (or is it $30 trillion?) in global goosing by central governments runs out of exponential-debt creation magic.
China's orders rolling over sounds the death-knell for all the industrial commodities like copper, crude oil and iron ore. Once the "global boom is re-inflating" story expires, so too will speculative demand for commodities.
Chart Four: FHA mortgages are souring at an incredible rate.
FHA has backed most of the mortgages originated since the global markets crashed in 2008. That those loans are defaulting reveals that the FHA has no more credible risk management than the subprime originators who inflated the housing/credit bubble before it (mostly Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, with help from Wall Street MBS packagers).
Chart Five: mortgages delinquencies are skyrocketing.
If 2009 was a year of recovery, there is little evidence of that in this chart. So-called "prime" 30-year fixed mortgages and Jumbo loans are both souring, too, despite all the happy stories about "this is limited to subprime loans."
Chart Six: mortgage reset are set to rise.
This is a newly updated chart of all the mortgage resets just ahead. It is difficult to swallow the MSM pablum that the housing market is "recovering" if you glance at this chart.
Chart Seven: maybe even gold is set to roll over.
This chart of the gold ETF GLD illustrates how volatile gold is as an asset, and it sure looks like gold is either taking a breather or set to roll over in one of its typical 6-to-12-month declines.
Why would gold decline if all other assets are falling? Perhaps because some owners will need to raise cash as their debts come due, and they will dump the one asset which is holding its value (gold) before they liquidate their fast-falling assets (i.e. "slope of hope" deleveraging in which you sell your best assets first in the hope your other assets will somehow recover).
The scenario for bonds is straightforward: as interest rates rise in response to a new appreciation for risk and default, the value of all bonds falls. Today's news of rising inflation in China just adds a little fuel to the higher-rates-ahead fire.
Chart Eight: the UUP ETF, a proxy for the U.S. Dollar.
The lowly dollar has been kicked around for several years--with good reason-- and the pundits calling for it to crash are legion. Perhaps, but the chart suggests the trend has reversed and the bruised DXY/USD might actually be in a new uptrend.
Why would the USD rise while everything else plummets? One possibility is a "relative flight to risk" and liquidity. If rates pop up globally (for the reason there isn't enough money, fiat or otherwise, to fund all the debt which is being floated or rolled over globally) then a modest return and a liquid market might look fairly attractive.
It's possible that a lot of this seeking-safety money could flow into gold and silver (and other precious metals), but it's also possible that the PM markets aren't large enough or liquid enough for such a flood of money, and it's also possible that many big-money managers might need some yield, however modest.
In this amateur observer's thought-experiment (which is NOT investment advice---please read the HUGE GIANT BIG FAT DISCLAIMER below), cash (and/or a short position) would be the only assets which retained or gained value.
Please note this is a speculative thought-experiment, not a strategy.
By way of disclosure: I am short various markets via puts on BAC and APC
and inverse leveraged ETFs. I have no long positions and I am holding a significant
percentage of my tiny portfolio in cash. I sold my gold mining stocks some months ago
and will patiently await a re-entry point. Please do not interpret this disclosure
as "advice;" I am posting this in response to a reader who suggested that what I own/
don't own is a better indication of my views that what I might write. Fair enough,
and those are my positions: cash and short.
is now open for aggregating our collective intelligence.
Of Two Minds is now available via Kindle: Of Two Minds blog-Kindle
"This guy is THE leading visionary on reality.
He routinely discusses things which no one else has talked about, yet,
turn out to be quite relevant months later."
NOTE: contributions are acknowledged in the order received. Your name and email remain confidential and will not be given to any other individual, company or agency.
Or send him coins, stamps or quatloos via mail--please request P.O. Box address.
Your readership is greatly appreciated with or without a donation.
For more on this subject and a wide array of other topics, please visit
All content, HTML coding, format design, design elements and images copyright © 2010 Charles Hugh Smith, All rights reserved in all media, unless otherwise credited or noted.
I would be honored if you linked this wEssay to your site, or printed a copy for your own use.
|consulting||blog fiction/novels articles my hidden history books/films what's for dinner||home email me|